Page 4 - Ovarian Cancer Surgery - Quality Indicators
P. 4

3 Method

QIs for advanced ovarian cancer surgery were developed using a four-step evaluation process Figure 1. The
strengths of the process include creation of a multidisciplinary international development group, use of scientific
evidence and/or international expert consensus to support the QIs, use of an international external review process
 physicians and patients , use of a structured format to present the QIs, and management of potential conflicts of
interests.

It is inspired by published development processes and initiatives6-117 identified from a literature search carried
out 1 using a list of selected websites see Appendix 2, a nd 2 in Medline without any restriction in the search
period indexing terms: consensus, development process, e vidence-based medicine, method, methodology,
methodology research, program development, quality assurance, quality improvement, quality indicators, quality
management). This development process involved 3 face to face meetings of the international experts panel,
chaired by Professor Denis Querleu Institut Bergonié, Bordeaux, France convened in May 19, 2015 , in
September 4, 2015, and January 25, 2016.

                                            Nomination of multidisciplinary international development group

              Identification of potential QIs N = 15

Evaluation#1                    Identification of scientific evidence                     1st meeting
Evaluation#2
              International experts independently evaluate the relevance and
                                         feasibility of each QI

                 International experts panel discussion of each potential QI
                               10 quality indicators were retained

                                  Synthesis of scientific evidence

Evaluation#3    External panel of physicians and patients international reviewers)        2nd meeting
Evaluation#4             evaluates the relevance and feasibility of retained QIs          3rd meeting

              International experts panel discussion and integration of external panel
                                                     comments

               Final decision on definition of QIs, specifications, targets, and scoring
                                                       system

                 Figure 1. Development process - A four-step evaluation process

               OVARIAN CANCER SURGERY - QUALITY INDICATORS 
                                                     4
   1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8   9